Oscillatory mechanisms supporting human cognition

The primary objective of the project is to acquire new knowledge about the fundamental electrophysiological mechanisms that enable working memory, prediction and attentional control in the human brain.

These basic cognitive control functions mentioned are critical for goal-directed thinking and behavior, and are crucial aspects of cognition that enable humans to successfully engage their surroundings. We hope to elucidate how networks of neurons in the brain cooperate when people perform tasks that make demands on participants' focusing of attention, anticipating upcoming stimuli, working memory, and other cognitive control functions. It is our belief that this will facilitate identification of the neural mechanisms by which the frontal cortex controls distributed neuronal ensembles in other brain regions that are engaged during higher-order cognition.

Brain imagery. Illustration.

By recording electrophysiological activity from electrodes directly attached to the surface of the brain or implanted in the depth of the brain, we are beginning to gain novel insights into the brain's oscillatory dynamics when performing cognitive tasks. Our ability to record directly from the brain is possible due to a unique population of individuals that opt to have electrodes implanted in their brain. These electrodes aid doctors in the process of localizing epileptic activity prior to surgical treatment for drug-resistant epilepsy. This method is called intracranial EEG (iEEG). iEEG is a powerful technique with unparalleled temporal and spatial resolution that permits detailed examination of the dynamic interplay of cortical processing within local- and across distant brain regions. No other electrophysiological recording technique offers the same precision, timing, or ability to observe cognition in real-time.

To the left: A man sitting in a hospital bed with a hood on his head that records EEG activity. On a table beside him is two computers. Photo. To the right: Brain imagery. Illustration.
Patient performing a test of attention and working memory during simultaneous registration of EEG activity recorded from intracranial electrodes.

Over the past few years, we have recorded data from the brains of the majority of adult patients who have undergone iEEG monitoring at the Department of Neurosurgery at Oslo University Hospital. All of these patients have participated in experiments designed to highlight the neural activity at work in directed attention and working memory. In conjunction with our iEEG recordings, we have also had the opportunity to record scalp-EEG data for the same experiments from neurological patients who have focal brain lesions (typically resulting from primary brain tumors) and from healthy volunteers. The integrated methodological approach that we utilize is beneficial because it allows us to test whether lesions to specific frontal regions disrupt the cognitive functions in question, and whether those regions play a key role in modulating the task-related electrophysiological activity we are interested in. By analyzing iEEG data, scalp-EEG data from neurological patients, and from healthy participants, we are able to examine how the brain manifests higher-order cognitive functions at varying levels of ability and what anatomical regions are required.

The Norwegian part of our team is composed of clinicians and researchers at the Department of Neurosurgery - OUS Rikshospitalet and the Department of Psychology/RITMO - University of Oslo. In collaboration with the Norwegian cohort are our colleagues at the University of California at Berkeley (USA). Data are recorded both at a Norwegian hospital and at US hospitals. Because iEEG data in Norway are only collected at Oslo University Hospital, combining data from Norway and the US greatly increases study participation and the feasibility of the project. Thus far, our international team has published high-impact scientific articles and given presentations at conferences on topics such as the characterization of bidirectional oscillatory communication that supports working memory; revealing neural mechanisms involved in predictive processes; defining a network of frontal and temporal regions that support top-down and bottom-up driven attention; and how the interplay between low and high frequency oscillations supports perception. More joint scientific reports have been submitted or are in preparation that are expected to provide new and groundbreaking insights into the neurophysiological basis of key cognitive control functions in the human brain.

Publications

  • Weber, Jan; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Anais, Llorens; Funderud, Ingrid & Leske, Sabine Liliana [Show all 11 contributors for this article] (2024). Ramping dynamics and theta oscillations reflect dissociable signatures during rule-guided human behavior. Nature Communications. ISSN 2041-1723. 15(1). doi: 10.1038/s41467-023-44571-7.
  • Asko, Olgerta; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Foldal, Maja Dyhre; Anais, Llorens & Funderud, Ingrid [Show all 10 contributors for this article] (2023). Altered hierarchical auditory predictive processing after lesions to the orbitofrontal cortex. bioRxiv. ISSN 2692-8205. doi: 10.1101/2023.01.04.521570.
  • Fuhrer, Julian; Glette, Kyrre; Anais, Llorens; Endestad, Tor; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin & Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar (2023). Quantifying evoked responses through information-theoretical measures. Frontiers in Neuroinformatics. ISSN 1662-5196. 17. doi: 10.3389/fninf.2023.1128866. Full text in Research Archive
  • Anais, Llorens; Bellier, Ludovic; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Ivanovic, Jugoslav; Larsson, P?l Gunnar & Lin, Jack J. [Show all 9 contributors for this article] (2023). Decision and response monitoring during working memory are sequentially represented in the human insula. iScience. ISSN 2589-0042. 26(10). doi: 10.1016/j.isci.2023.107653. Full text in Research Archive
  • Weber, Jan; Iwama, Gabriela; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Larsson, P?l Gunnar & Ivanovic, Jugoslav [Show all 9 contributors for this article] (2023). Subspace partitioning in the human prefrontal cortex resolves cognitive interference. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. ISSN 0027-8424. 120(28). doi: 10.1073/pnas.2220523120. Full text in Research Archive
  • Johnson, Elizabeth L.; Chang, William K.; Dewar, Callum D.; Sorensen, Donna; Lin, Jack J. & Solbakk, Anne-Kristin [Show all 12 contributors for this article] (2022). Orbitofrontal cortex governs working memory for temporal order. Current Biology. ISSN 0960-9822. 32(9), p. R410–R411. doi: 10.1016/j.cub.2022.03.074.
  • Fuhrer, Julian; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Endestad, Tor; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin & Glette, Kyrre (2022). Complexity-based Encoded Information Quantification in Neurophysiological Recordings. Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC). ISSN 2694-0604. p. 2319–2323. doi: 10.1109/EMBC48229.2022.9871501.
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Ivanovic, Jugoslav; Larsson, P?l Gunnar; Knight, Robert Thomas & Endestad, Tor (2022). Modeling intracranial electrodes. A simulation platform for the evaluation of localization algorithms. Frontiers in Neuroinformatics. ISSN 1662-5196. 16, p. 1–20. doi: 10.3389/fninf.2022.788685. Full text in Research Archive
  • Foldal, Maja Dyhre; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Endestad, Tor & Solbakk, Anne-Kristin (2022). Attentional modulation of beta-power aligns with the timing of behaviorally relevant rhythmic sounds. Cerebral Cortex. ISSN 1047-3211. 33(5), p. 1876–1894. doi: 10.1093/cercor/bhac179.
  • Katarina Slama, Slama; Jimenez, Richard; Saha, Sujayam; King-Stephens, David; Laxer, Kenneth D. & Weber, Peter B. [Show all 12 contributors for this article] (2021). Intracranial recordings demonstrate both cortical and medial temporal lobe engagement in visual search in humans. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience. ISSN 0898-929X. 33(9), p. 1833–1861. doi: 10.1162/jocn_a_01739.
  • Buades-Rotger, Macià; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Liebrand, Matthias; Endestad, Tor; Funderud, Ingrid & Siegwardt, Paul [Show all 9 contributors for this article] (2021). Patients with ventromedial prefrontal lesions show an implicit approach bias to angry faces. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience. ISSN 0898-929X. 33(6), p. 1069–1081. doi: 10.1162/jocn_a_01706.
  • Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Lubell, James; Leske, Sabine; Funderud, Ingrid; Anais, Llorens & Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar [Show all 10 contributors for this article] (2021). Monitoring of self-paced action timing and sensory outcomes after lesions to the orbitofrontal cortex. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience. ISSN 0898-929X. 33(9), p. 1956–1975. doi: 10.1162/jocn_a_01733.
  • Liebrand, Matthias; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Funderud, Ingrid; Buades-Rotger, Macià; Knight, Robert Thomas & Kr?mer, Ulrike M (2021). Intact Proactive Motor Inhibition after Unilateral Prefrontal Cortex or Basal Ganglia Lesions. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience. ISSN 0898-929X. 33(9), p. 1862–1879. doi: 10.1162/jocn_a_01691.
  • Llorens, Ana?s; Funderud, Ingrid; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Lubell, James; Foldal, Maja Dyhre & Leske, Sabine Liliana [Show all 11 contributors for this article] (2020). Preservation of Interference Effects in Working Memory After Orbitofrontal Damage. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. ISSN 1662-5161. 13, p. 1–15. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2019.00445. Full text in Research Archive
  • Foldal, Maja Dyhre; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Llorens, Ana?s; Knight, Robert T.; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin & Endestad, Tor (2020). The brain tracks auditory rhythm predictability independent of selective attention. Scientific Reports. ISSN 2045-2322. 10, p. 1–13. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-64758-y. Full text in Research Archive
  • Kam, Julia W.Y.; Helfrich, Randolph H.; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Endestad, Tor; Larsson, P?l Gunnar & Lin, Jack J. [Show all 7 contributors for this article] (2020). Top-Down Attentional Modulation in Human Frontal Cortex: Differential Engagement during External and Internal Attention. Cerebral Cortex. ISSN 1047-3211. 31(2), p. 873–883. doi: 10.1093/cercor/bhaa262.
  • Sadaghiani, Sepideh; Dombert, Pascasie L.; L?vstad, Marianne; Funderud, Ingrid; Meling, Torstein Ragnar & Endestad, Tor [Show all 9 contributors for this article] (2019). Lesions to the fronto-parietal network impact alpha-band phase synchrony and cognitive control. Cerebral Cortex. ISSN 1047-3211. 29(10), p. 4143–4153. doi: 10.1093/cercor/bhy296.
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Collavini, Santiago; Lubell, James; Anais, Llorens; Funderud, Ingrid & Ivanovic, Jugoslav [Show all 13 contributors for this article] (2019). Auditory deviance detection in the human insula: An intracranial EEG study. Cortex. ISSN 0010-9452. 121, p. 189–200. doi: 10.1016/j.cortex.2019.09.002. Full text in Research Archive
  • Kam, Julia W.Y.; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Endestad, Tor; Meling, Torstein Ragnar & Knight, Robert Thomas (2018). Lateral prefrontal cortex lesion impairs regulation of internally and externally directed attention. NeuroImage. ISSN 1053-8119. 175(15), p. 91–99. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2018.03.063.
  • Johnson, Elizabeth L.; Adams, Jenna N.; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Endestad, Tor; Larsson, P?l Gunnar & Ivanovic, Jugoslav [Show all 9 contributors for this article] (2018). Dynamic frontotemporal systems process space and time in working memory. PLoS Biology. ISSN 1544-9173. 16(3). doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.2004274. Full text in Research Archive
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Phillips, Holly N.; Princich, Juan Pablo; Rowe, James B.; Bekinschtein, Tristan & Muravchik, Carlos [Show all 7 contributors for this article] (2017). iElectrodes: a comprehensive open-source toolbox for depth and subdural grid electrode localization. Frontiers in Neuroinformatics. ISSN 1662-5196. 11:14, p. 1–16. doi: 10.3389/fninf.2017.00014. Full text in Research Archive
  • Perry, Anat; Saunders, Samantha N.; Stiso, Jennifer; Dewar, Callum; Lubell, James & Meling, Torstein Ragnar [Show all 9 contributors for this article] (2017). Effects of prefrontal cortex damage on emotion understanding: EEG and behavioural evidence. Brain. ISSN 0006-8950. 140(4), p. 1086–1099. doi: 10.1093/brain/awx031.
  • Johnson, Elizabeth L.; Dewar, Callum; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Endestad, Tor; Meling, Torstein Ragnar & Knight, Robert T (2017). Bidirectional Frontoparietal Oscillatory Systems Support Working Memory. Current Biology. ISSN 0960-9822. 27(12), p. 1829–1835. doi: 10.1016/j.cub.2017.05.046. Full text in Research Archive
  • Helfrich, Randolph Fredrik; Huang, Melody; Wilson, Guy & Knight, Robert T. (2017). Prefrontal cortex modulates posterior alpha oscillations during top-down guided visual perception. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. ISSN 0027-8424. 114(35), p. 9457–9462. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1705965114.
  • Helfrich, Randolph Fredrik & Knight, Robert T. (2016). Oscillatory dynamics of prefrontal cognitive control. Trends in Cognitive Sciences. ISSN 1364-6613. 20(12), p. 916–930. doi: 10.1016/j.tics.2016.09.007.

View all works in Cristin

  • Asko, Olgerta; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Meling, Torstein Ragnar; Knight, Robert T. & Endestad, Tor [Show all 7 contributors for this article] (2023). The orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) has a critical role in the generation of high-level expectations.
  • Asko, Olgerta; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Meling, Torstein Ragnar; Knight, Robert T. & Endestad, Tor [Show all 7 contributors for this article] (2023). Orbitofrontal lesion impacts formation of auditory expectations.
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Llorens, Ana?s; Funderud, Ingrid & Larsson, P?l Gunnar [Show all 10 contributors for this article] (2023). Temporal and precentral brain activity in automatic auditory deviance detection. Evidence from human intracranial EEG recordings.
  • Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Leske, Sabine Liliana & Endestad, Tor (2023). Orbitofrontal lesion impacts formation of auditory expectations.
  • Rezende Carvalho, Vinicius; Collavini, Santiago; Kochen, Silvia; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin & Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar (2023). Single-neuron responses to a multifeature oddball paradigm.
  • Leske, Sabine Liliana; Endestad, Tor; Volehaugen, Vegard; Foldal, Maja Dyhre; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar & Solbakk, Anne-Kristin [Show all 7 contributors for this article] (2023). Predicting the Beat Bin – Beta Oscillations Support Top-Down Prediction of The Temporal Precision of a Beat .
  • Volehaugen, Vegard; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Funderud, Ingrid; Llorens, Ana?s; Carvalho, Vinicius Rezende & Endestad, Tor [Show all 8 contributors for this article] (2023). Echoes of the unheard: An intracranial electrophysiology study of expectation and attention in auditory omission processing.
  • Malmierca, Manuel S.; Auksztulewicz, Ryszard; Teichert, Tobias; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar & Melloni, Lucia (2022). The Neuronal basis of predictive coding: Evidence from brain studies across species.
  • Fuhrer, Julian; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Endestad, Tor; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin & Glette, Kyrre (2022). Complexity-Based Encoded Information Quantification in Neurophysiological Recordings.
  • Volehaugen, Vegard; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Endestad, Tor; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin & Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar (2022). Violation of rule-based auditory patterns is detected independently of attention.
  • Fuhrer, Julian; Glette, Kyrre; Ivanovic, Jugoslav; Larsson, P?l Gunnar; Bekinschtein, Tristan & Kochen, Silvia [Show all 10 contributors for this article] (2022). Direct brain recordings reveal continuous encoding of structure in random stimuli.
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Llorens, Ana?s; Funderud, Ingrid & Collavini, Santiago [Show all 13 contributors for this article] (2022). Human brain network involved in auditory deviance detection. An intracranial EEG study.
  • Asko, Olgerta; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Foldal, Maja Dyhre; Llorens, Ana?s & Funderud, Ingrid [Show all 10 contributors for this article] (2022). Altered hierarchical auditory predictive processing after lesions to the orbitofrontal cortex.
  • Fuhrer, Julian; Glette, Kyrre; Ivanovic, Jugoslav; Larsson, P?l Gunnar; Bekinschtein, Tristan & Kochen, Silvia [Show all 10 contributors for this article] (2022). Direct brain recordings reveal continuous encoding of structure in random stimuli.
  • Leske, Sabine Liliana (2022). Inter-Trial Coherence (ITC).
  • Leske, Sabine Liliana (2022). Fourier Transform.
  • Leske, Sabine Liliana (2022). Phase Amplitude Coupling (PAC).
  • Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Endestad, Tor & Knight, Robert Thomas (2022). Oslo - Berkeley collaboration in cognitive neuroscience and neuropsychology.
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar (2021). Electrode localization in intracranial EEG. From simulations to novel electrode localization and brain-shift correction algorithms. .
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar (2021). Some advances in neuroscience using intracranial EEG recordings.
  • Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Lubell, James Isaac; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Llorens, Anais & Funderud, Ingrid [Show all 13 contributors for this article] (2021). Auditory prediction and prediction error in self-generated tones.
  • Fuhrer, Julian; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; T?rresen, Jim; Endestad, Tor & Glette, Kyrre (2019). Making Sense of Randomness?
  • Leske, Sabine Liliana; Lubell, James Isaac; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Llorens, Ana?s; Funderud, Ingrid & Foldal, Maja Dyhre [Show all 13 contributors for this article] (2019). Auditory prediction and prediction error in self-generated tones.
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Lubell, James; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Llorens, Ana?s & Funderud, Ingrid [Show all 14 contributors for this article] (2019). Human brain network involved in auditory deviance detection: Evidence from intracranial EEG recordings.
  • Leske, Sabine Liliana; Lubell, James; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Llorens, Ana?s; Funderud, Ingrid & Foldal, Maja Dyhre [Show all 13 contributors for this article] (2019). Action-based auditory predictions.
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar (2019). Auditory deviance detection network in the human brain.
  • Westner, Britta; Andersen, Lau M?ller; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar & Leske, Sabine Liliana (2019). RITMO International EEG FieldTrip workshop, Lectures and Hands-on sessions .
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar (2019). Origins of the EEG signal and Technical setup of EEG.
  • Spiech, Connor (2019). Predicting the Groove: A Combined EEG-Pupillometry Study.
  • Foldal, Maja Dyhre; Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Llorens, Ana?s; Knight, Robert Thomas; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin & Endestad, Tor (2019). The brain tracks global temporal regularity in auditory patterns.
  • Spiech, Connor (2019). Predicting the Groove: A Combined EEG-Pupillometry Study.
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Lubell, James; Leske, Sabine Liliana; Llorens, Ana?s & Funderud, Ingrid [Show all 14 contributors for this article] (2019). Human brain network involved in auditory deviance detection: Evidence from intracranial EEG recordings.
  • Endestad, Tor; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Ivanovic, Jugoslav; Larsson, P?l Gunnar; Knight, Robert T. & Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar (2019). A robust intracranial electrode localization algorithm.
  • Kam, Julia W.Y.; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Funderud, Ingrid; Endestad, Tor; Meling, Torstein Ragnar & Knight, Robert Thomas (2018). Orbitofrontal damage reduces auditory sensory response in humans. Cortex. ISSN 0010-9452. 101, p. 309–312. doi: 10.1016/j.cortex.2017.12.023.
  • Blenkmann, Alejandro Omar; Lubell, James; Llorens, Anais; Funderud, Ingrid; Collavini, Santiago & Larsson, PG [Show all 13 contributors for this article] (2018). Human insula response to auditory deviants: Evidence from intracranial EEG recordings.
  • Kam, Julia W.Y.; Lin, Jack J.; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Endestad, Tor; Larsson, P?l Gunnar & Knight, Robert T. (2018). Functional coupling between default network and fronto-parietal control network supports internally directed attention. .
  • Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Endestad, Tor & Knight, Robert T. (2018). Neural oscillations and human behavior.
  • Kam, J.W.Y.; Lin, J.J.; Endestad, Tor; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Larsson, P.G. & Griffin, S. [Show all 7 contributors for this article] (2017). Contributions of medial prefrontal cortex to internally directed attention.
  • Johnson, Elizabeth L.; Adams, J.N.; Griffin, S.M.; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Endestad, Tor & Larsson, P.G. [Show all 9 contributors for this article] (2017). Dynamic frontotemporal systems for episodic working memory.
  • Johnson, Elizabeth L.; Dewar, C.; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Endestad, Tor; Meling, Torstein Ragnar & Knight, Robert T. (2017). Causal evidence that bidirectional frontoparietal rhythms support working memory.
  • Slama, S.J.K.; Solbakk, Anne-Kristin; Endestad, Tor; Larsson, P.G.; Lin, Jack J. & King-Stephens, D. [Show all 9 contributors for this article] (2017). Intracranial recordings define a cortical-mesial temporal network in top-down and bottom-up attention.

View all works in Cristin

Published Mar. 13, 2019 8:35 PM - Last modified Feb. 14, 2023 11:47 AM

Participants

  • Anne-Kristin Solbakk University of Oslo
  • Tor Endestad University of Oslo
  • Alejandro Omar Blenkmann University of Oslo
  • Ingrid Funderud University of Oslo
  • Sabine Liliana Leske University of Oslo
  • Vegard Akselsson Volehaugen University of Oslo
  • Vinicius Rezende Carvalho University of Oslo
  • Maja Dyhre Foldal University of Oslo
  • Anne Danielsen University of Oslo
  • Rahul Omprakash Agrawal University of Oslo
  • Olgerta Asko University of Oslo
  • Anais Llorens (Dept. of Psychology, UiO and UC Berkeley, USA)
  • Jamie Lubell (Dept. of Psychology, Univ. of Oslo)
  • P?l Gunner Larsson (OUS-RH)
  • Jugo Ivanovic (OUS-RH)
  • Torstein R. Meling (National Hospital, Copenhagen, Denmark)
  • Robert T. Knight (UC Berkeley, USA)
  • Julia Kam (UC Berkeley, USA)
  • Lisa Johnson (UC Berkeley, USA)
  • Randolph F. Helfrich (UC Berkeley, USA & Univ. of Tubingen, Germany)
  • Julian Fuhrer (RITMO and Dept. of Informatics, UiO)
  • Katarina Slama (UC Berkeley, USA)
  • Ulrike M Kr?mer (UC Berkeley/Univ. of Lubeck, Germany)
  • Matthias Liebrand (Univ. of Lubeck, Germany)
  • Sepideh Sadaghiani (UC Berkeley, USA)
  • Macià Buades-Rotger (Univ. of Lubeck, Germany)
  • Anat Perry (UC Berkeley)
Detailed list of participants